Bloomberg Columnists
 |
|
Joe Mysak is a
columnist for Bloomberg News. The opinions expressed are his
own. |
Indiana Sells Road for Billions; Prepare
for Deluge: Joe Mysak
Jan. 25 (Bloomberg) -- Now that Indiana has sold its toll
road, get ready for everyone else to do the same.
On Monday, Governor Mitch Daniels said a Spanish-Australian
consortium had bid $3.85 billion to run the Indiana Toll Road, a
157-mile highway across northern Indiana that runs from the
Illinois to Ohio, for 75 years.
The legislature still has to approve the proposal, of course,
but they're not going it alone with this concept. Indiana
lawmakers have only to look north, to Illinois, for another
example of how this kind of thing works. Last year, Chicago got
$1.8 billion for its Skyway, a 7.8-mile long elevated highway
that connects the Dan Ryan Expressway with the Indiana Toll
Road. Lots of public officials took notice.
A Merrill Lynch & Co. report published last July on the
subject of U.S. toll road privatization asked whether sales like
the Skyway were one-offs, ``or do they represent the beginning
of a sweeping trend that will spread to other tolled bridges,
tunnels, expressways and long-distance toll roads?''
Let's bet on the sweeping trend. The money is just too big to
resist, and the business of running toll roads just too marginal
to what state governments are all about.
Now that Illinois and Indiana have done it, look for other
states to dive right in.
Red State
Merrill Lynch estimates that at least 18 states from
California to Massachusetts have state-, county-, or city-owned
toll roads that might lend themselves to privatization. In fact,
there are probably candidates in almost all 50 states. What you
need is an established road, and the flexibility to increase
tolls.
Don't underestimate the importance of Indiana, rather than,
say, New Jersey, doing this, either. Indiana is one of the
Republican-dominated red states, and one with a reputation for
fiscal rectitude.
Standard & Poor's, in upgrading the state to AA+ from AA on
Jan. 23, observed that ``debt levels remain among the lowest in
the nation at less than $379 on a per capita basis and just
above 1 percent of personal income.''
We are going to see more of these transactions, and the
numbers are going to get bigger and bigger. It was estimated
last year that New Jersey might get $30 billion for the state's
Turnpike and Parkway, for example. That would cure a lot of
Governor Jon Corzine's headaches.
Merrill Lynch estimated that the New York State Thruway
Authority might be worth something like $20 billion.
Sell the Roads
So now the cry will go up: Sell the roads!
Owners don't actually sell, of course; they sign a long- term
lease with a company to operate and maintain the roads in
exchange for an up-front payment. The lease agreements include
details of things like toll increases and maintenance standards.
Governor Daniels of Indiana plans to use the $3.85 billion
that he expects to receive from Australia's Macquarie
Infrastructure Group and Cintra Concesiones de Infraestructuras
de Transporte SA of Madrid, to improve and expand the state's
highways. In theory, the state could do anything with the money.
The state is also going to use about $200 million of the
upfront payment to redeem outstanding toll road bonds. Merrill
Lynch noted last year that ``the emergence of this trend offers
municipal bond investors dynamic opportunities -- likely
resulting in defeasances of outstanding bonds.''
This means there are guys out there combing through the
billions of dollars in bonds that have been sold for toll road
financing from coast to coast, coming up with likely candidates.
In a toll road that is ``underperforming,'' -- meaning, not
enough people are using it -- the sale of the road could mean
that bonds now trading for 70 cents or 80 cents on the dollar
will rise to 100 or more.
Show Them the Money
The sticky matter for Governor Daniels is selling the state's
lawmakers, and everyone else in Indiana, for that matter, on the
idea. But we've come a long way from the days where people felt
bad about selling assets like landmark buildings and other
property to foreign investors.
Remember all the hysteria back in the 1980s about Japan Inc.
buying up skyscrapers? People evidently thought that the new
owners would disassemble the things and move them back to Tokyo.
There might be some resistance to the idea, at first, but expect
that to fade. The money is just too big.
|